CSEC Mathematics · algebra
Proving Algebraic Identities
Before you start
You already know how to expand single and double brackets using the distributive law, collect like terms, and factorise expressions by taking out common factors.
Builds on: Simplifying Algebraic Expressions, Distributive Law: Expanding and Factorising
1. Equations vs. Identities
In algebra, students often see the equals sign (=) and assume every statement is an equation to be solved. However, there is a key difference between an equation and an identity:
- An equation is a mathematical statement that is true only for specific values of the variable. For example, 2x+5=11 is an equation because it is only true when x=3. If you plug in x=4, the statement is false (13=11).
- An identity is a statement connecting two expressions that is true for all possible values of the variable. For instance, 2(x+3)=2x+6 is an identity because no matter what number you choose for x (whether x=0, x=−7, or x=100), the left-hand side will always equal the right-hand side.
In advanced mathematics, the symbol ≡ (is identically equal to) is sometimes used for identities, but in CSEC exams, the standard equals sign (=) is commonly used. You determine whether a statement is an identity by simplifying one or both sides to see if they produce identical expressions.
Worked example
Determine whether 4(2x−3)+7=8x−5 is an equation or an identity.
- Take the Left-Hand Side (LHS): LHS=4(2x−3)+7.
- Expand the bracket using the distributive law: 4(2x)−4(3)+7=8x−12+7.
- Collect the constant terms: 8x−5.
- Compare with the Right-Hand Side (RHS): RHS=8x−5.
- Since LHS=RHS for all values of x, the statement is an identity.
Answer: The statement 4(2x−3)+7=8x−5 is an identity because the left-hand side simplifies to the exact expression on the right-hand side.
Quick check
Which of the following mathematical statements represents an identity?
2. Proving Identities by Expanding Brackets
When a CSEC question asks you to "Show that..." or "Prove that..." an identity is true, it is giving you the final destination ahead of time. Your job is to provide the step-by-step algebraic pathway showing how one side turns into the other.
Golden Rule for Proving Identities:
1. Choose one side to work on—almost always the more complicated side (usually the Left-Hand Side, LHS).
2. Expand brackets carefully, watching negative signs especially when expanding perfect squares like (a−b)2=a2−2ab+b2 or products like (a+b)(a−b)=a2−b2.
3. Collect like terms.
4. Show clearly that your simplified expression matches the Right-Hand Side (RHS).
5. Conclude with a clear statement: **LHS=RHS**.
Worked example
Show that (2x+3)2−(2x−3)2=24x.
- State the side you are working on: LHS=(2x+3)2−(2x−3)2.
- Expand the first perfect square: (2x+3)2=(2x)2+2(2x)(3)+32=4x2+12x+9.
- Expand the second perfect square: (2x−3)2=(2x)2−2(2x)(3)+32=4x2−12x+9.
- Subtract the second expansion from the first, keeping brackets around the second term to distribute the negative sign correctly: LHS=(4x2+12x+9)−(4x2−12x+9).
- Remove brackets by distributing the minus sign: 4x2+12x+9−4x2+12x−9.
- Group and collect like terms: (4x2−4x2)+(12x+12x)+(9−9)=24x.
- Notice that this equals the Right-Hand Side: LHS=RHS.
Answer: LHS=(4x2+12x+9)−(4x2−12x+9)=24x=RHS. Thus, the identity is proved.
Quick check
Show that (x+4)(x−4)+16=x2. Write out your working starting with the LHS.
3. Proving Identities Using Common Factors
In higher-mark CSEC questions, you may encounter expressions with multiple bracketed terms that look long and intimidating. Often, expanding everything into separate terms creates tedious polynomial expansions where errors easily creep in.
An alternative, elegant strategy is to look for common algebraic factors before multiplying out:
- Identify if there is a common bracket shared between terms, such as (a+b) or (x−y).
- Factor out the common bracket using the distributive law in reverse.
- Simplify what remains inside the second bracket.
- Complete any remaining multiplications to reach the target RHS.
Worked example
Show that (x+y)2(x−y)−xy(x−y)=x3−y3.
- Write down the LHS: LHS=(x+y)2(x−y)−xy(x−y).
- Notice that both terms share the common bracket factor (x−y): factorise it out.
- LHS=(x−y)[(x+y)2−xy].
- Expand the inner bracket: (x+y)2=x2+2xy+y2.
- Substitute back into the square bracket: (x−y)[x2+2xy+y2−xy].
- Simplify like terms inside the bracket: (x−y)(x2+xy+y2).
- Expand this product: x(x2+xy+y2)−y(x2+xy+y2)=x3+x2y+xy2−x2y−xy2−y3.
- Collect like terms: x3−y3.
- Compare with RHS: LHS=RHS.
Answer: Factoring out (x−y) gives (x−y)(x2+xy+y2), which expands to x3−y3=RHS.
Quick check
Factorise the common bracket in (p+1)2−3(p+1) and simplify your answer completely.
Common mistakes
- Treating an identity like an equation to solve: Never move terms across the equals sign (e.g. subtracting terms from both sides). Work strictly on one side until it matches the other.
- Forgetting the middle term when squaring a binomial: Writing (a+b)2 as a2+b2 is an extremely common error. Always remember (a+b)2=a2+2ab+b2.
- Dropping brackets after a subtraction sign: When subtracting an expression like −(x2−4x+4), every single term inside changes sign to −x2+4x−4.
In the exam
- CSEC awards Method marks (M marks) for each clear step of algebraic expansion and grouping. Always write 'LHS =' and show your expansions before simplifying.
- End your proof with a concluding line such as 'LHS = RHS (proved)' so the CXC examiner knows you have completed the demonstration.
- If you get stuck expanding from the LHS, expand the RHS on rough paper to see what target expression you need to reach in the middle.
Key terms
- Identity
- An algebraic statement connecting two expressions that is true for all possible numerical values of the variables.
- Equation
- A mathematical statement that is true only for specific values of the variable (its solutions or roots).
- LHS and RHS
- Abbreviations for 'Left-Hand Side' and 'Right-Hand Side' of a mathematical statement.
- Difference of Two Squares
- The identity (a+b)(a−b)=a2−b2.
Practice
Easier to harder. Use paper for your working.
Practice 1
Which of the following statements is an EQUATION and NOT an identity?
Practice 2
Prove that (3x+1)2−6x=9x2+1. Show your working clearly starting from the LHS.
Practice 3
Show that (m−2n)2+8mn=(m+2n)2. Show that the LHS expands to the same expression as the RHS.
Now try real past-paper questions
1 Paper 2 question on this topic. Quelpr marks your working point by point, like an examiner.
- Mathematics Q8 8(b) · 3 marksShow that (a-b)² (a + b) + ab(a+b) = a³ + b³.
Finished the lesson?
0 of 6 checks right on this device.
Read more
- Collins - Concise Revision Course for CSEC Mathematics, p. 177
- Mathematics for CSEC, p. 48
- CSEC Maths Study Guide - Maths Crash Course, p. 159
- precalculus-2e_-_WEB, p. 686
- CXC Study Guide - Mathematics for CSEC, pp. 95, 97
- CSEC Maths Study Guide (Revised 2016), p. 33