CSEC Mathematics · algebra
Binary Operations
Before you start
A binary operation is simply a rule for combining two numbers to get a single number. You already know four standard binary operations: addition (+), subtraction (−), multiplication (×), and division (÷).
1. Evaluating Non-Standard Binary Operations
In CSEC Mathematics, examiners invent new operations using special symbols such as ∗, Δ, ⊙, or ⋄. These are called non-standard binary operations.
Every binary operation comes with a formula defining how the two numbers combine. The rule simply tells you what to substitute:
- The first letter in the definition represents the first number.
- The second letter represents the second number.
To evaluate an expression, replace the variables with the given values and simplify using the standard rules of arithmetic (BODMAS), paying close attention to negative signs.
Worked example
A binary operation ∗ is defined on real numbers by x∗y=3x2−2y. Calculate the value of 4∗(−3).
- Identify the variables: here x=4 and y=−3.
- Substitute into the given rule: 4∗(−3)=3(4)2−2(−3).
- Evaluate powers first: 42=16, giving 3(16)−2(−3).
- Multiply the terms: 3×16=48 and −2×(−3)=+6.
- Add the results: 48+6=54.
Answer: 4∗(−3)=54
Quick check
A binary operation ⊙ is defined by a⊙b=2a2−3b. Evaluate 3⊙4.
2. Compound Operations and Brackets
When an expression contains more than one operation symbol or includes brackets, treat it just like ordinary arithmetic:
- Work inside brackets first.
- Use the result of that bracket as one of the inputs for the outer operation.
For example, to find (a∗b)∗c, you first calculate the value of a∗b, then apply the operation ∗ to that answer and c.
Worked example
The operation ⋄ is defined by m⋄n=2m+n−3. Calculate the value of (3⋄5)⋄2.
- Work out the bracket (3⋄5) first: substitute m=3 and n=5.
- 3⋄5=2(3)+5−3=6+5−3=8.
- Now replace (3⋄5) with 8 in the full expression: we need to find 8⋄2.
- Substitute m=8 and n=2 into the rule: 8⋄2=2(8)+2−3.
- Simplify: 16+2−3=15.
Answer: (3⋄5)⋄2=15
Quick check
The binary operation ∗ is defined by p∗q=pq−p. Calculate the value of 2∗(3∗4).
3. Testing Properties: Commutative and Associative Laws
CSEC frequently asks whether an operation is commutative or associative.
1. Commutative Law: An operation ∗ is commutative if changing the order does not change the result:
- *To prove it is commutative:* Show algebraically that the expression for a∗b simplifies to the exact same expression as b∗a.
- *To disprove it (prove it is NOT commutative):* Provide a single numerical counter-example showing that a∗b=b∗a.
2. Associative Law: An operation ∗ is associative if grouping does not change the result:
- Again, a single numerical counter-example is sufficient to prove an operation is not associative.
Worked example
A binary operation is defined on real numbers by a∗b=2a+b. Determine whether ∗ is commutative. Justify your answer.
- State the definition of commutativity: ∗ is commutative if a∗b=b∗a for all real numbers.
- Write the algebraic expression for each order: a∗b=2a+b, and b∗a=2b+a.
- Notice that 2a+b=2b+a in general.
- Provide a specific counter-example: let a=1 and b=3.
- Calculate 1∗3=2(1)+3=2+3=5.
- Calculate 3∗1=2(3)+1=6+1=7.
- Conclude clearly: since 1∗3=3∗1, the operation ∗ is not commutative.
Answer: The operation ∗ is not commutative because 1∗3=5 while 3∗1=7, so 1∗3=3∗1.
Quick check
A binary operation Δ is defined by xΔy=x2+y2. Show algebraically whether Δ is commutative.
Common mistakes
- Reversing the order of substitution: in a∗b, the first number must always replace a and the second must replace b. Swapping them leads to wrong answers unless the operation is commutative.
- Neglecting directed number rules: miscalculating signs such as −(−4) or (−3)2. Remember that squaring a negative number yields a positive result, and subtracting a negative is equivalent to adding.
- Assuming an operation is commutative after testing only one pair of identical numbers (like 2∗2). To disprove commutativity, choose two different numbers (a=b).
In the exam
- Always write out the substitution step explicitly before calculating. CSEC awards a method mark (M1) just for correctly placing the numbers into the formula.
- When asked to 'Justify your answer' for proving an operation is not commutative, stating 'No' alone scores 0 marks. You must show the numerical calculations for both a∗b and b∗a and state that they are not equal.
Key terms
- Binary Operation
- A rule that combines two elements from a set to produce a single element.
- Commutative
- A property where the order of operands does not affect the outcome: a∗b=b∗a.
- Associative
- A property where grouping does not affect the outcome: (a∗b)∗c=a∗(b∗c).
- Counter-example
- A specific case or set of numbers that proves a mathematical statement or property is false.
Practice
Easier to harder. Use paper for your working.
Practice 1
Given that m∗n=√m+3n, where the positive square root is taken, evaluate 4∗7.
Practice 2
A binary operation ∘ is defined as a∘b=a2−2b. What is the value of (3∘2)∘4?
Practice 3
A binary operation is defined by x∗y=xyx−y for all non-zero numbers x and y. Determine whether ∗ is commutative. Justify your answer.
Now try real past-paper questions
3 Paper 2 questions and 3 Paper 1 multiple-choice on this topic. Quelpr marks your working point by point, like an examiner.
- Mathematics Q2 2(a)(ii) · 3 marksGiven that a * b means √(a + 4b), where the positive root is taken. Determine whether the operation denoted by * is commutative. Justify your answer.
- Mathematics Q2 2(b) · 2 marksBinary operation * defined as a * b = (a + b)² - 2ab. Calculate the value of 3 * 4.
- Mathematics Q2 2(b) · 1 markIf a * b = a² - b, evaluate 5 * 2.
Finished the lesson?
0 of 6 checks right on this device.
Read more
- Collins - Concise Revision Course for CSEC Mathematics, pp. 140, 141, 155
- Mathematics for CSEC, p. 207
- CSEC Maths Study Guide - Maths Crash Course, p. 139
- CXC Study Guide - Mathematics for CSEC, pp. 92, 93