Quelpr

CSEC Mathematics · statistics

Choosing the Best Average

Determine whether the mean, median, or mode is the most appropriate measure of average for different scales of measurement and real-life situations.
15 min Syllabus: determine the appropriate measure of average across different scales of measurement

Before you start

You already know how to calculate the mean (the sum of values divided by the total number of values), the median (the middle value of an ordered list), and the mode (the most frequently occurring value).

Builds on: Measures of Central Tendency

1. Scales of Measurement and Qualitative Data

Statistical data is collected on different scales of measurement:

  • Nominal scale: Qualitative categories or labels with no natural numerical order (e.g., eye colour, gender, favourite cricket team).
  • Ordinal scale: Categories that have a distinct order or ranking, but the difference between ranks is not fixed or measurable (e.g., race positions: 1st, 2nd, 3rd; satisfaction ratings: poor, fair, good).
  • Interval and Ratio scales: Numerical measurements where differences have exact mathematical meaning (e.g., temperature, mass in kilograms, money in dollars). A ratio scale has a true zero (such as length or mass: 0 cm means absence of length).

When data is nominal (qualitative), you cannot add values or arrange them in numerical order. Therefore, the mode is the only average that can be used.

Bar chart showing student preferences for lunch items at a school canteen.0102030405060RotiPelauPattyBake & SharkLunch ChoiceNumber of Students

Worked example

The canteen manager at a secondary school in San Fernando records the lunch choices of 160 students as shown in the bar chart. Identify the type of data and state which average (mean, median, or mode) the manager should use to decide which dish to prepare the most.

Bar chart showing lunch choices of 160 students: Pelau 55, Roti 40, Fried Rice 35, Macaroni Pie 20, and Sandwich 10.0102030405060PelauRotiFried RiceMacaroni PieSandwichLunch ChoiceNumber of Students
  1. Identify the data type: The choices (Pelau, Roti, Fried Rice, Macaroni Pie, Sandwich) are names/categories, so the data is nominal (qualitative).
  2. Determine which averages are possible: You cannot sum or find the middle rank of non-numerical food names, so the mean and median cannot be calculated.
  3. Select the appropriate average: The mode identifies the category with the highest frequency (Pelau with 55 students).

Answer: The data is nominal (qualitative), so the mode is the only appropriate average. The manager should prepare more Pelau, as it is the modal choice.

Quick check

A poll asks voters in Kingston to name their favourite radio station. Which average can be determined from this survey?

2. Numerical Data: Mean vs Median and the Effect of Outliers

For numerical data (interval and ratio scales), all three averages can be calculated, but they serve different purposes:

  • The Mean uses every piece of data. It is ideal when you need to calculate totals because:
Total=Mean×n

However, the mean is heavily distorted by outliers (extreme values that are much higher or lower than the rest).

  • The Median is the middle value. It is not affected by extreme outliers. If a dataset contains a few unusually high or low values, the median gives a much better representation of a 'typical' value than the mean.
  • The Mode shows the most popular value. It is useful for manufacturers and retailers deciding which specific size or item to stock most.

Worked example

Five workers at a small carpentry workshop in Guyana earn monthly wages of 3,000,3,100, 3,200,3,500, and $25,000 (the owner's salary). Calculate the mean and the median, and state which average better represents a typical worker's monthly wage.

  1. Calculate the mean: Mean=53000+3100+3200+3500+25000​=537800​=\7,560$.
  2. Find the median: The values are already ordered. The middle (3rd) value is \3,200$.
  3. Compare with the data: Four of the five workers earn between \3,000and\3,500. The mean of \7,560isdistortedupwardsbythesingleextremevalueof\25,000 (an outlier).
  4. Conclude: The median reflects the typical wage far better than the mean.

Answer: Mean = 7,560;Median=3,200. The median is the more appropriate average because the outlier ($25,000) distorts the mean.

Quick check

The test scores of seven students are 12, 14, 15, 15, 16, 18, and 98. Why is the median preferred over the mean to represent typical performance?

3. Matching the Average to the Purpose

In CSEC exam questions, you are often asked to state which average is most appropriate and give a reason. Use this decision framework:

Purpose / Data CharacteristicBest AverageStandard CSEC Justification
Planning a budget, total cost, or total expenditureMeanIt uses all data values and satisfies Total=Mean×n.
Skewed numerical data or presence of extreme outliersMedianIt is not affected by extreme values/outliers.
Qualitative / Categorical items (e.g. colours, brands)ModeNon-numerical data cannot be summed or ordered.
Stocking inventory or finding the single most common sizeModeIdentifies the item with the highest frequency.

Worked example

A school Sports Master wants to purchase 200 pairs of running shoes for inter-school athletics. Explain whether the mean, median, or mode shoe size should be used to decide how many of each shoe size to order.

  1. Consider what shoe size represents: Even though shoe sizes are numbers, an 'average' like a mean shoe size of 8.3 is not a real shoe size.
  2. Consider the goal: The Sports Master must know which specific sizes are requested most often so the supplier can provide enough pairs of each size.
  3. Select the average: The mode identifies the most common shoe sizes to guide stock quantities.

Answer: The mode is most appropriate because shoe sizes are discrete categories, and the Sports Master needs to know the most frequent sizes to purchase.

Quick check

A tour operator needs to estimate the total fuel expense for 30 bus trips next month based on sample records from previous trips. State which average (mean, median, or mode) fuel cost per trip is most appropriate, and give a reason.

Common mistakes

  • Choosing the mean for categorical (nominal) data. You cannot calculate the mean of shirt colours or food preferences because labels cannot be added.
  • Using the median or mode to estimate total budgets. Only the mean links directly to the sum: Total=Mean×n. Multiplying the median by n does not give the true total.
  • Claiming the mean is best simply because 'it is the most common average'. CSEC requires you to mention that the mean uses every piece of data, or state whether outliers are present.

In the exam

  • In 2-mark questions, 1 mark is awarded for naming the correct measure and 1 mark for the reason. Never write just 'mean' or 'median' without a clear explanation.
  • When justifying the median, always use the keyword 'outlier' or 'extreme value'.
  • When justifying the mean for financial or planning questions, explain that it allows the calculation of the total amount (extTotal=extMeanimesn).

Key terms

Nominal Scale
A scale of measurement involving distinct categories or labels that cannot be ordered mathematically.
Outlier
An extreme data value that lies an unusually large distance away from the rest of the values in a dataset.
Mean
The average calculated by dividing the sum of all values by the number of values; it utilizes all data points.
Median
The middle value in an ordered set of data; resistant to extreme values.
Mode
The most frequently occurring value or category in a dataset.

Practice

Easier to harder. Use paper for your working.

Practice 1

A vendor selling school uniforms in Bridgetown wants to decide which skirt waist sizes to order for the upcoming school term. Which average should she use?

Practice 2

A village council in Tobago is budgeting the total cost of installing streetlights along 15 roadways. The costs per roadway vary slightly. Which average (mean, median, or mode) is MOST appropriate for estimating the total project cost? Give a reason.

Practice 3

House prices in a certain neighbourhood in Saint Lucia are: 220,000,240,000, 250,000,260,000, and $2,800,000. State which average is MOST appropriate to describe the typical price of a house in this neighbourhood, and give a reason.

Now try real past-paper questions

1 Paper 2 question on this topic. Quelpr marks your working point by point, like an examiner.

  • Mathematics Q6 6(d) · 2 marksThe P.T.A. plans to set up a transportation service for the school. Which average, mean, mode or median, is MOST appropriate for estimating the cost of the service? Give a reason…

Finished the lesson?

0 of 6 checks right on this device.

Read more

  • CXC Study Guide - Mathematics for CSEC, pp. 69, 70, 71